The faith of Plaxton has been ambiguous over the years to say the least. On several occasions he's posted references to the occult on Facebook, particularly favoring articles praising Anton LaVey - founder of the Church of Satan. However, several times, Plaxton has refuted both being a Satanist or an atheist. Plaxton has called himself "religious" and claimed he's not really sure if the "guy up there" is named "muhammad, Jesus, or whatever", conflicting with his outspoken hatred towards Muslims. Plaxton attends Resurrection Life Church, a non-denominational Christian church several times a week. He also attends their young singles group "Pipeline" and often posts about going to eat at places such as Shoney's and IHOP with his "Pipeline guys".